Kohler vs. Generac: A Detailed Comparison for Homeowners

Power outages are becoming more common as increasingly unpredictable weather patterns bring stronger storms and heat waves. This highlights the importance of having a reliable backup power source—a generator—to ensure your home remains comfortable and functional during outages.

Two leading brands dominate the home standby generator market: Kohler and Generac. Both companies offer various options, but choosing the right one for your needs can be challenging. This comparison will help you understand the key differences between these two generators brands, allowing you to make an informed decision.

Kohler Generators: A Legacy of Quality

Kohler, was founded in 1873, boasts a rich history of manufacturing high-quality products. Their foray into the generator market brings that same commitment to excellence. Here’s a closer look at Kohler generators:

Pros:

  • User-Friendly: Kohler generators are known for their ease of use. They typically feature automatic transfer switches, meaning the generator seamlessly takes over when the power goes out and switches back automatically when power is restored.
  • Easy Maintenance: Designed for straightforward upkeep, Kohler generators require minimal maintenance, ensuring long-term reliability and efficiency.
  • Durability: Built with robust construction, Kohler generators can withstand years of heavy use, providing dependable performance during critical outages.
  • Fuel Efficiency: Kohler generators are known for their fuel efficiency. They offer high power output while minimizing fuel consumption, which translates to lower operating costs over time.
 

Cons:

  • Higher Cost: One of Kohler generators’ main drawbacks is their higher price point compared to Generac. While this reflects the brand’s reputation for quality materials and craftsmanship, it can be a significant factor for budget-conscious buyers.
  • Noise Levels: While most generators produce some noise, Kohler units are known to operate at slightly higher decibel levels. This may require careful placement consideration, especially if noise is a major concern. 
  • Costly Repairs: Although Kohler generators are built to last, repairs, if needed, can be expensive. Additionally, complex repairs might require specialized technicians, further increasing the cost.
 

Generac Generators: A Focus on Affordability and Features

Founded in 1959, Generac quickly became a leader in the backup power generation market. Here’s what sets Generac generators apart:

Pros:

  • Affordable Prices: Generac generators are a more budget-friendly option than Kohler. This makes them attractive to a wider range of homeowners, especially those looking for value for money.
  • Wide Variety: Generac boasts many generators with different power outputs, fuel types, and features. This ensures you find a model that perfectly fits your needs and budget.
  • Self-Refueling Option: Some Generac models come with a convenient self-refueling system that can automatically draw natural gas directly from your home’s line, eliminating the need for manual refueling during outages.

Cons:

  • Noise Levels: Similar to Kohler, some Generac models generate higher noise levels. This needs to be considered for homeowners in quiet neighborhoods.
  • Recall Concerns: In 2023, Generac recalled over 60,000 generators due to potential safety and reliability issues. While this incident doesn’t necessarily reflect the quality of all Generac products, it highlights the importance of researching specific models before purchasing.
 

Head-to-Head Comparison:

Noise Levels:

This is relatively close. While Kohler units tend to be slightly louder, the difference might not be significant for most homeowners. Both brands offer quieter models, with specific decibel levels varying depending on the model.

Features:

Both Kohler and Generac offer a wide range of features, including automatic operation, multiple fuel options (LP gas and natural gas), and the ability to customize your power plan to select appliances or your entire home.

However, some noteworthy differences exist:

  • Kohler offers multiple power options tailored to specific needs. For example, their 14kW generator powers basic appliances like TVs, water heaters, and HVAC units, while the 26kW unit can power an entire house.
  • Generac: Offers Wifi connectivity on some models for remote monitoring and control.
 

Choosing the Right Generator for Your Home

When selecting a generator, consider these factors:

  • Power Needs: Determine the wattage of the appliances you want to power simultaneously.
  • Fuel Type: Consider the availability and cost of natural gas or propane in your area.
  • Noise Levels: If noise is a concern, look for quieter models with sound-dampening features.
  • Installation: Factor in the cost and complexity of professional installation.

Conclusion

Both Kohler and Generac offer reliable and high-quality generators. The best choice for you will depend on your specific needs, budget, and preferences. By carefully considering your options and consulting with a qualified professional, you can select the right generator to keep your home powered and protected during outages.